Framing this tale is a murder mystery involving Hector, who shoots someone who at first appears to be an innocent customer buying stamps. The answer to the mystery is supposed to be revealed as the war story unfolds, though the technique doesn't work. This highlights one of the film's major issues - it's too bulky. Rather than tell the story of a group of African-American soldiers - which according to Director Spike Lee was the reason for making the film - the movie instead places more focus on doling out messages. White officers are portrayed as uncaring and show little regard for their black compatriots. While I'm sure there is some truth to this, I'm also sure the issue wasn't as bleak as the film makes it seem. Not only does this remove some of the film's impact, but it undermines the film's core message.
Surprisingly enough, this message is better heard (and seen) in "The Buffalo Soldier Experience," a documentary that features interviews with Buffalo Soldier veterans. I got a better feel for their experience through this short twenty-minute documentary than I did during the nearly three-hour long movie.
Aside from the documentary, the other extras are lackluster. "Deeds not Words" is a roundtable discussion with four WWII veterans, Spike Lee and screenwriter James McBride. This feature is at its best when the veterans tell their stories.
Miracle at St. Anna is just an okay war movie. When it sticks to the story, it's an enjoyable movie. However, story seems to come second to the multiple messages, resulting in a bulky, cumbersome movie.
