If you're going to test a product for durability and protection, you want to expose it to extremes. For us, the extreme was a trip to E3 2011. I took my 3DS-encased
Catalyst everywhere during the trip. It went through the crowded show floor, rode the Los Angeles Metro and was my constant companion through my airport adventure home.
I was impressed at how well the Catalyst stood up to the trip's rigors. I think my 3DS even managed to come out of the event in better shape than most of the staff. The case held its grip under the constant stress of being pulled in and out of my bag's side-pocket several times a day (you know, every time I checked to see my latest SpotPass buddies). I was a little worried one of the pieces might come loose, but it is a nice, tight grip.
Installation is an easy slip-on and takes under five minutes. Removing the case takes a little longer, but you want that from a case. If it's easy to remove, it is not that great for protection, is it?
The Catalyst's soft finish feels great in your hands. It is not leather, but from a distance it looks like it, giving the device a more sophisticated look. The fabric is, as far as I can tell, scratch resistant. In addition to surviving E3, I've also taken my 3DS out when I go for runs around the neighborhood (the pedometer function is great). Even though my 3DS has slipped out of my pocket twice, you wouldn't be able to tell it met the pavement. There's one smaller scratch, though it is only noticeable under the right lighting conditions.
The case adds a little extra to the 3DS's size, though I liked the added weight and grip. The natural bottom of the 3DS felt thin and a bit slippery, so the Catalyst adds just the right amount of grip. The extra form factor is just enough to offer protection, though I can still easily slip my 3DS into my pocket.
